These are some general suggestions about how to do your
research paper. The most important advice is to get started early and
to come
talk to me often. There is a lot of work to be done for a project like
this,
and if you get started early and work steadily the whole process is a
lot more
enjoyable. Remember that research at IUP involves a lot of PALCI and
ILL, so
get started early. It also helps to talk to someone about what is
happening
with the project and any problems you might be having. I am always
available
and happy to talk to you.
Developing a topic
Choosing
and developing a topic is the most important part of the research
process. You
need to pick a topic that will interest you (you are going to spend a
lot of
time on this), a topic you can find sources for, and a topic you can
say
something about.
One way to
pick a topic is to pick a large (and available) primary source or set
of
documents and start going through it trying to see if you can come up
with a
question that you could answer from it. Or you could start with a topic
and
then try to see if there are sources around that would help you to deal
with
it. Almost always the topic you start with will be too vague and need
to be
narrowed or changed. You need to be looking for a question to answer or
a
thesis to defend. Initially the research will probably be geared
towards a
paper like “Random facts about the early Manchu empire” but it has to
get
beyond that to become a good, or even an acceptable, paper.
Sometimes you end up shifting your
topic because what you started with was too broad, or unfocused.
Sometimes you
shift because the sources will not let you talk about one thing but
will let
you talk about another.
Doing Research
Once you
have a general topic you need to start doing research. Finding the
sources you
are going to use is really more an art than a science. Part of it of
course is
a matter of keeping at it. As you read about your topic you find lots
of leads.
Some of them will pan out, some of them will not. The more of them you
follow
the more stuff you will find. Usually research tends to go from the
more
general to the more specific, i.e. you start with fairly general
sources that
are comparatively easy to find and then move towards more specific
things that
are harder to find and less likely to be of use, but more useful if you
do find
something.
Probably
the easiest place to start is with on-line journal databases like JSTOR
and
Project Muse, and WorldCat. Going through the bibliographies of
secondary works
and looking for subject bibliographies are also helpful. Keeping track
of what
you find with bibliographic software like Endnote will save you a lot
of time
later and also helps if you end up shifting your topic. Remember that
research
at IUP involves a lot of PALCI and ILL, so get started early.
Assessing your
sources
As you are collecting sources it
is important to assess what they are and what good they are for you.
Initially
the process of research is just collecting citations, which is fine,
and makes
you feel good, but you don’t really know what you have until you start
looking
at things. Does this article say something I want to know? Does it have
any
citations that I should track down? Is it too technical for me to
understand?
You don’t have to read the whole thing to figure this out, but you do
need to
learn to quickly assess a source and see what you have. Research is
like mining
for gold. You can find lots of shiny rocks, but you don’t really know
if they
are any good until you assay them. As you are looking at these things
at
figuring out what they say you will also be refining your topic and
figuring
out what you need, which will guide your future research.
Starting to write
It is almost always a good idea
to start writing somewhere in the middle of the paper. You may not yet
know
what your thesis is and there may be huge parts of the paper you have
not yet
figured out, but you can start to write at least some of it. There are
a number
of advantages to this. Part of it is that it will make you feel better.
Look,
pages are piling up. It will also help you realize what gaps are in
your
research and probably help you to come up with ideas for the rest of
the paper.
Finishing writing
As the paper grows you need to
figure out what exactly the paper as a whole is trying to say. This may
change
several times, which is fine. The paper must have a clear and
significant
thesis. At the beginning of the paper you make a bargain with your
reader. If
you keep reading, I will explain why X is Y. Note that as you write you
can
change the bargain (X is Z), but in the final draft you need to make a
deal and
keep it.
This is
also a good time to think about the organization of your paper. Does
this
section really belong here? Can I cut these two pages down to a
paragraph? It
is hard to do these things first because it is hard to toss out your
deathless
prose and second because it is hard to realize that a section -can- be
moved
when it has been there for ages. You need to make a shift from reading
the
paper like the author to reading it like a reader. Yes, you understand
what you
are doing. Will they? How are you helping the reader through the paper?
Filling in the gaps
The last part you write is
always the hardest. You left it for the end for a reason, after all.
Introductions and conclusions are also hard. Don’t let the problems
with these
things keep you from filling in other gaps. Keep researching. Often you
have
problems with a section because you don’t have the sources, If you
treat
research like a process to be finished before writing you will remain
stuck.
Research and writing should inform each other. Look for good quotes or
statistics that will help you to make your points. The first draft is
almost
always your voice, but what you really want is your voice explaining
that the
sources prove that X is Y.
Revision
Once everything is done and you
are sure the paper is entirely perfect set it down for a week or so and
then
look at it again. You will find lots of things to fix. Note that to do
this you
need to get started early.
Have fun
This may seem like strange
advice, but you should enjoy the process of research and writing. This
is what
historians do, and if you don’t like it you are in the wrong place.
And, frankly,
it is lots of fun if done right. Usually when I find myself hating a
project it
is because I realize I am not doing a very good job on it.